| Platinum | Papa's & Beer Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | Ay Caramba Mexican Grill |
| Silver | Mamas & Beer |
| Bronze | Papa's Express Asheville Mall |
| Top Pick | El Chapala Mexican |
| Top Pick | El Que Pasa |
| Top Pick | LA Carreta |
| Top Pick | Nachos & Beer |
| Top Pick | Taqueria Munoz |
| Top Pick | Tortilleria Molina |