| Platinum | El Chapala Mexican |
| Gold | El Que Pasa |
| Silver | Tortilleria Molina |
| Bronze | Papa's & Beer Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Ay Caramba Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Cantina Louie |
| Top Pick | Chupacabra Latin Cafe |
| Top Pick | El Rebozo Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Elenas |
| Top Pick | Taco Billy |